The true embodiment of Joseph
Campbell's 'hero' is not a question of either or when it comes to Lucas’
characters, Luke Skywalker and Han Solo. It is only when both of these hero's
paths are evaluated that Campbell's definition of the hero’s journey becomes
realized. They both go through different ways of defeating the power of the
Dark Side. Luke directly combats the dark side and his feelings of anger when
he fights his father Darth Vader. Han Solo has to deal with his selfish
tendencies and his proclivity for distrust.
I do believe that Luke Skywalker is the
main hero in the Star Wars Trilogy. He is depicted going through most of what
Joseph Campbell defines as the “hero’s Journey.” However, what Luke lacks is
what is discussed in the short essay “The Civic Hero and the Contemplative
Hero,” he lacks the capacity as a romantic hero. He is the contemplative hero,
who reaches his goal through an inner look at his self and the principles he
has been taught by the Supernatural Aid. I also don’t think his character made
such a radical change when comparing it the change found within Han Solo.
Throughout the movie, although he does go through the difficulties of resisting
the Dark Force and the allure of a relationship with his father, I found him
still to be a rather static character. Always trying to do the right thing,
save his friends no matter what, use the force etc. This might just be my
distaste for what I find to be an overly earnest Mark Hamill, but I was never
surprised by any of Luke Skywalker’s actions. So I’m going to argue Han Solo as
the embodiment of the hero.
Han Solo is the quintessential loner who
rejects the company of everyone but his sidekick, Chewbacca the Wookie. When
Han is first encountered he is the epitome of selfishness and is motivated only
by rewards and his resolve to save his own skin. In Episode IV the hen the
Millennium Falcon is first captured by Imperial forces, Han’s only prerogative
is to save his own skin. He only agrees to assist in helping Princess Leia when
he is told that she is rich and there will be great reward if she is saved.
This is a constant strain in the first movie in the trilogy, but his
development towards heroism is first displayed when he comes back to help Luke
destroy the first Death Star, even despite his claim that “what’s good a
reward, if you ain’t around to use it”. As Pfeiffer and Lewis mention, in the
second film is when we really get “to know him better” as a hero and a truly
viable character (105). Despite his loudly proclaimed convictions that he
should just take care of himself and depend on no one, he constantly puts
himself into danger for his new found friends. An example of this would be in
the beginning of Episode V when he first puts off his plans to leave the rebel
base in order to search for Luke and his later decision to take Leia with him
when they flee the base because of the approaching Death Star. He eventually
learns to accept his place as “civic hero,” learning to “negotiate that world,
to overcome the temptations of the world, and finally serve the world in a
leadership capacity.” He is the hero who in this movie experiences what
Campbell calls the “ultimate adventure.” The meeting of the goddess, who in
this film is Leia the “brave leader” leader of the rebel movement, and winning
her love, is the final test of talent. Campbell says that this represents the “hero’s
total mastery of life.” Basically, Han is ‘winning.’
You raise excellent points! It's easy enough to argue that Luke is the hero as he goes through Campbell's outline of a Hero's Journey from A Hero With A Thousand Faces (and for the fact that our class discussions basically answered this for us.) Examining all the characters for their combined contributions is always the answer when it comes to literature. Indeed, both the characters in question take on the enemy, the Dark Side. Luke most certainly does not fulfill any role as a romantic hero. That is an excellent point to bring up. Han's role, even though seeming diminished in Return of the Jedi, fulfills the other side of the action in the film. Star Wars is not just popular for the battle that Luke faces with his father or the power of the Force. Star Wars has explosions in space! Han faces the physical battles and wins… with a few exceptions. The nature of his role fits the idea of a 'civic hero' as he puts himself in danger to save his friends. Like the last image we have from A New Hope, they are both honored in front of the ginormous crowd as they both are heroes. In this respect, Han's hero status is vital to the success of the trilogy.
ReplyDelete